Beating the French at the cheese game

14:30 06 May 2009

A selection of regional cheeses...

A selection of regional cheeses...

British cheesemakers produce over 450 unique cheeses - more than in France. Sue Braithwaite reports on the rise of real cheese.

Artisan cheese is a product which above all reflects the essential local aspects of that subtle mixture of physical location, animal husbandry and farming techniques which the winemakers call 'terroir'.

A good cheesemaker understands how to exploit the differing qualities of the milk each season, which in turn are due to changes in weather and the food being grazed by the herd.

These individual, variously shaped and differently rinded cheeses are a world away from the uniform yellow, shrink wrapped blocks which too many of us have become accustomed to by the onward march of the supermarket. And don't be deceived by the modern use of the word 'farmhouse', unfortunately it has no legal significance and can be used by anyone to try and 'legitimise' the product.

Traditionally, a farmhouse cheese was just that, one developed on the farm as a way of preserving the milk from the dairy, all cheeses would have been made with raw milk and the by-product, whey, fed to the pigs - nothing was wasted.

A range of cheeses would be produced on each farm - fresh, soft ones to eat straightaway, lightly pressed ones to store for a short time and hard-pressed ones, wrapped in muslin or calico to last through the winter. Since Roman times, these local and regional cheeses have been recorded literally in their hundreds.

Talk to many artisan cheesemakers and they will tell you that the subtleties in the milk which they are trying to bring out in their cheese are really only present in raw, unpasteurised milk. There are bacteria in all cheeses which give them their individual character and flavour.

As well as killing off any possible bad bacteria, the heating process of pasteurisation also kill off the helpful ones, making it much harder to make anything like a decent product and requiring laboratory cultures to be added back during the cheesemaking process.

Many cheesemakers also feel bludgeoned by regulations and lack of support from local authorities to change or revert back to raw milk. There is a lot of history to counter.

The homogenisation of our British cheeses started in the late 1800s as the growth in transportation led to essentially local products being moved around the country. Cheeses which up to that time would have been known by the name of the farm or farmer, started to acquire names, usually denoting the region of production - Lancashire, Caerphilly, Stilton or Gloucester - so they could be identified further afield.

The advent of the Milk Marketing Board in 1913 enabled farmers to sell in their milk to a central 'distributor' rather than process it themselves. This also brought about mass-pasteurisation, partly to kill off diseases but also to extend the milk's shelf life.

The tide of industrialisation continued along with the introduction of ever more 'rules'. Conformity became the goal. For example, during the Second World War the Ministry of Food only recognised four types of cheese Cheddar, Cheshire, Leicester and Wensleydale. If you didn't comply, it was often easier to give up.

In spite of the history and food hygiene issues, and after a long decline, we are now seeing a revival of artisan cheesemaking in the UK as farmers look to diversify and develop value-added products for consumers who are increasingly looking for interest, localness and variety.

A recent count shows that The Specialist Cheesemakers Association has over 150 registered members in Britain, making over 450 unique cheeses (we possibly have more individually different cheeses now than the French!) Many of these are made using raw milk in spite of the 'lysteria hysteria' which seems to pop up every time there is some other food scare.

The three Worcestershire cheesemakers - Lightwoods in Lower Broadheath which uses exclusively raw milk, Gorsehill Abbey near Broadway which uses organic cows milk from their own herd and Anstey's of Worcester which uses both pasteurised and unpasteurised milk - all make some fine cheeses and are worth searching out.

Unfortunately John and Margaret Jenkins of Mar Goats in Little Witley stopped making their wonderful goats cheeses some time ago, but alongside their cows' milk cheeses Phil Hulland of Lightwoods has recently launched two soft goats cheeses - Capria and Rhapsody - and Colin Anstey makes a tangy hard one called Snodsbury.

A cheeseboard made up exclusively from the region's producers would take you through cow's, ewe's and goat's milk, fresh, soft, semi-soft and hard, smoked and unsmoked and even some blue. Like all small producers, they are continually refining their products and bringing new ones to the market often testing them out with loyal customers during the development process and always looking for feedback.

So take a real or virtual tour round the region's cheeses and decide for yourself if raw, organic or pasteurised makes a difference - but above all enjoy the fantastic quality and variety.

Old Fashioned Cheese Pudding

A simple dish which you can dress up if you feel like it. Makes a light supper or try it sliced and fried for breakfast. Use a strong cheese such as Lightwood's Elgar Mature.

225g grated cheese
570ml whole milk
110g breadcrumbs
75g streaky bacon, preferably in a piece (optional)
2 free range eggs, beaten
½ teaspoon, mustard powder or freshly grated nutmeg

Heat the milk to just under boiling point and add the breadcrumbs. Leave to stand for at least an hour. If using, cut the bacon into small chunks or strips and fry in a dry pan until crispy. Drain on kitchen paper. When you are ready to prepare the dish, gently reheat the milk and bread mixture and when hot, stir in the cheese and mix to ensure all the cheese has melted. Remove from the heat and add the beaten egg, bacon, seasoning and mustard if you are using the bacon, or if not the nutmeg. Pour the mixture into a well buttered ovenproof dish. Bake in the oven preheated to 180°C/375°F/gas mark 3 for 35-40 minutes until the pudding is fairly firm. Leave to stand for a couple of minutes before serving.

Regional cheeses

A selection of fine cheeses from the eleven traditional cheesemakers of Herefordshire, Shropshire, Warwickshire and Worcestershire. For expert advice why not visit The Moustrap in either Leominster, Hereford or Ludlow? Run by the hugely knowledgeable Mark Hindle of Monkland Dairy, these specialist cheese shops stock an outstanding range of the best local and British cheeses alongside more well known European ones.

Monkland Cheese. 01568 720307

Little Hereford, unpasteurised, made to a traditional Herefordshire recipe. Matured for 3-4 months for a good lingering flavour

Monkland, unpasteurised, brine-bathed cheese, fresh tasting with a crumbly texture

Neal's Yard Creamery 01981 500395

Finn, organic, unpasteurised, cream enriched cheese, with a soft creamy white mould rind

Dorstone, unpasteurised, ash rind goats cheese with a mouse-like texture


Appleby's of Hawkstone. 01948 840387

Cheshire, pasteurised, traditional Cheshire

Ludlow Food Centre 01584 856000

Cheese with no name, a mould ripened soft cheese with a creamy texture

Remembered Hills Blue, full flavoured blue cheese in the stilton style

Mr Moyden 01952 810798

Wrekin White, unpasteurised, full bodied cheese matured for 6 months.

Newport 1665, unpasteurised, smoked at Bings Heath Smokery, mellow, buttery flavour with flaky texture

Shropshire Cheese Company 01691 828765

Tanataside, pasteurised, similar to Wenslydale, dry, slightly crumbly texture


Fowlers of Earslwood. 01564 702329

Warwickshire truckle, pasteurised, made to a traditional recipe. Cheddar-like, cloth bound and waxed

Forest Blue, pasteurised, firm creamy texture, similar to a good Stilton

Ram Hall Farm. 01676 532203

Berkswell, unpasteurised, hard ewe's mik cheese, matured for 6 months with a nutty, tangy full flavour


Anstey's. 01905 820232

Double Worcester, pasteurised, similar to double Gloucester

Snodsbury, a hard cheese made with unpasteurised goats milk

Gorsehill Abbey. 01386 852208

St Eadburgha, organic, soft brie-like, matured for 4-12 weeks

Cotswold, a range of organic soft fresh cream cheeses

Lightwood Cheese. 01905 333468

Elgar Mature, unpasteurised, strong cloth bound cheddar

Chaser, unpasteurised, cream enriched soft cheese

Lightwood also makes fabulous hand-churned butter


Shop with us at Great British Life

More from Food & Drink

Tuesday, July 21, 2015
Receive a free hessian bag when you spend over £50

Cotswolds Distillery, producers of outstanding natural spirits, are delighted to offer readers of Cotswold Life a free Hessian bag for life with purchases over £50 in our on-site shop.

Read more
Friday, July 17, 2015
Alex James at the launch of the Big Feastival at his farm in Kingham

These nine Cotswold food ambassadors have one thing in common, a passion for good quality food and drink, locally sourced where possible. Between them they have championed their cause across the Cotswolds and beyond; the Cotswolds should be very proud of them.

Read more
Wednesday, July 15, 2015
The Centaur at Cheltenham Racecourse before the guests arrive | Photo by Thousand World Media

Want to know what happened at one of the biggest events in the Cotswold calendar? Cotswold TV were there to catch the best bits from the glittering Food and Drink Awards night

Read more
Tuesday, July 14, 2015
Come along to our VZUG cookery demos and enjoy 5 delicious courses of effortless Swiss efficiency.

Professional chefs have been cooking with steam for years, and thanks to the ever advancing capabilities of domestic tech, home kitchens are also now enjoying the steam revolution. Angela Bower at Bower Willis Designs tells us more.

Read more
Tuesday, July 14, 2015
(Getty Images/iStockphoto)

With the sixth series of the Great British Bake Off set to hit screens soon, we find out how life has changed for past contestants

Read more
Thursday, July 9, 2015
There were many excellent restaurants that made the shortlist for the Cotswold Life Food & Drink Awards 2015 | Image: Natalia Hubbert

Following on from the Cotswold Life Food & Drink Awards ceremony earlier this July, we’ve put together a list of the top restaurants shortlisted, including the finalists and winners from across the various categories.

Read more
Tuesday, July 7, 2015
Cotswold Life Food & Drink Awards stage l © Thousand Word Media

In a glittering awards night at Cheltenham Racecourse on July 6, 450 guests gathered to celebrate the region’s food and drink industry in what is undoubtedly one of the biggest events in the Cotswold calendar. Here we announce the winners

Read more
Tuesday, July 7, 2015
BBQ for Heroes raises funds for Help For Heroes, which provides injured service personnel with ongoing support

Help for Heroes is asking the great British public to turn their BBQ’s in to an opportunity to fundraise for our wounded, injured and sick service personnel, veterans and their families.

Read more
Thursday, July 2, 2015
Afternoon Tea in the Cotswolds | Image: Molesko Studio

Afternoon Tea, once the preserve of high society, is now widely available in cafés, tearooms and restaurants across Britain. This is no less true in the Cotswolds, where you can delight in a cream tea or sip a delicate speciality blend in virtually every town and village in the region. To help you choose, here’s our selection of the best places to enjoy afternoon tea around the Cotswolds.

Read more
Wednesday, June 24, 2015
Organic Asparagus and Hollandaise Tart by Emily Watkins

With the British asparagus season drawing to a close, this delicious recipe from chef Emily Watkins is a perfect way to celebrate the ingredient.

Read more
Monday, June 22, 2015
The Cotswolds is famous for its picturesque landscape, perfect for a picnic | Image: KPG Ivary

There are many beautiful spots in and around the Cotswolds to lay your blanket down and enjoy a good old fashioned picnic! Here’s our pick of the best.

Read more
Friday, June 5, 2015
Mary Berry visits Upton House which during the Second World War became the 'bank to beat the blitz'

When Mary Berry popped in to Upton House to officially launch its new wartime exhibition, we were thrilled to be able to have a chat with her about her wartime memories, her affection for the Cotswolds, and much more besides...

Read more
Wednesday, May 27, 2015
Fancy a pint? [Photo: Nikolay Litov]

Whether you’re a connoisseur or just fancy a tipple, there are ample festivals across the Cotswolds catering for beer, cider and wine lovers. Here’s our pick of the best, in chronological order.

Read more
Thursday, May 21, 2015
Gloucester Quays Food Festival

People in the Cotswolds are spoilt for choice when it comes to food festivals. Here is our pick of the best events celebrating all things great and edible in this pretty region of England.

Read more


Food and Drink Directory
subscription ad

subscription ad

Warwickshire's trusted business finder